Rare Beauty All of the Above Weightless Eyeshadow Stick: An In-Depth Review
Alyssia Chang
- Published
Are Rare Beauty All of the Above Weightless Eyeshadow Sticks worth it? This review assesses their blendability, convenience, and durability. Discover if they live up to the claims and suit your makeup needs.
Overall Review: 8.4
Pros
- Blendable easy to apply formula
- Long-lasting wear
- Built-in sharpener
- Vegan, cruelty-free
- Water resistant
Cons
- Prone to breaking under extreme heat
- High price point than some alternatives
- Low pigment score
- Not great with oily lids (use a primer!)
Key Takeaways
Rare Beauty’s All Of The Above Weightless Eyeshadow Sticks are praised for their creamy, blendable formula and long-lasting wear, making them perfect for quick and stylish eye makeup application.
The eyeshadow sticks come in sleek packaging with a built-in sharpener, and they are available in six versatile shades catering to different looks and occasions.
Despite minor drawbacks like slight breaking under high temperatures, these eyeshadow sticks stand out for their durability, crease-resistance, and ability to layer different shades effectively without blending into a muddy mess.
Introducing Rare Beauty Eyeshadow Sticks
Rare Beauty’s All Of The Above Weightless Eyeshadow Sticks super creamy, blendable gel eyeshadow sticks can be used to line your eyes or as an all-over color on the lids. They promise quick application and long-lasting wear, making them perfect for those who crave efficiency without compromising on style.
With a formula that includes ultra-fine, multidimensional pearls for a shimmering effect, Rare Beauty aims to cater to all skin types, providing a smooth and even application.
Rare Beauty’s eyeshadow sticks are all about that creamy, weightless formula that glides on easily and stays put all day.
They’re perfect for anyone who wants quick, fuss-free makeup that still delivers on performance.
The buzz around these sticks has got makeup lovers excited to play around with new looks again.
Despite the bold claims and growing fan base, it’s important for us to critically examine whether these eyeshadow sticks can truly live up to their promises. We’ll evaluate these claims and discover what Rare Beauty really offers.
Claims Under Scrutiny
Rare Beauty’s All Of The Above Weightless Eyeshadow Sticks make several bold claims that have piqued the interest of beauty lovers everywhere.
Among these, the most noteworthy are their promise of being crease-resistant, water-resistant, and suitable for all skin types. Additionally, these eyeshadow sticks are touted for their easy blending capabilities, making them an ideal choice for both makeup novices and experts alike.
However, as seasoned makeup users understand, extravagant claims should be viewed with a degree of skepticism. Will the eyeshadow sticks truly resist creasing and water? Are they as blendable as advertised? And can they really suit all skin types? I plan to test these claims closely to see if they hold up under various conditions.
Unboxing and Initial Impressions
“Unboxing the Rare Beauty All Of The Above Weightless Eyeshadow Sticks was pretty exciting. The sleek, modern packaging instantly stood out.
Our first impressions of the product were generally positive. Here are some key features that stood out to us:
The packaging isn’t just good-looking; it’s solid and feels durable too.
The built-in sharpener is a nice, practical touch.
You can tell they put a lot of thought into the design, which made unboxing it even more fun
Ingredients
Good Ingredients:
Dimethicone: Provides a smooth, silky texture and helps with blendability.
Tocopheryl Acetate: A form of Vitamin E, known for its antioxidant properties, which can help protect the skin.
Silica: Helps with oil absorption and gives a soft-focus effect, making the product long-lasting.
Bad Ingredients:
Trisiloxane: A type of silicone that can cause buildup on the skin, potentially leading to clogged pores over time.
Synthetic Fluorphlogopite: A synthetic version of mica, which can sometimes cause irritation for sensitive skin types.
Microcrystalline Wax: Can be heavy and potentially comedogenic, which means it might clog pores for some users.
TIP
If you’re worried about skin allergies or questionable ingredients, try a spot test on the back of your jawline first. If everything’s good after a few hours, you’re in the clear!
Getting Started with Application
Applying the Rare Beauty eyeshadow sticks is a breeze. You can apply them directly to the eyelid without the need for an eyeshadow brush BUT I highly recommend using a cream brush or your ring finger to blend.
For best results, we recommend starting with a light layer and building up the intensity to achieve your desired look.
PRO TIP: These eyeshadow sticks can also double as highlighters for specific areas like the inner corner of the eye or under the brow bone.
Sleek and Stylish Design
The design of the Rare Beauty All Of The Above Weightless Eyeshadow Sticks is nothing short of impressive. Their features include:
Slender, modern look that emphasizes portability
Matte finish on the casing for a sleek aesthetic and comfortable grip during application
Made from durable, lightweight materials to withstand daily use
These features make them a decent addition to your makeup bag.
The compact size means you can easily slip them into even the smallest of purses, making them ideal for travel or touch-ups throughout the day.
Plus, the built-in sharpener at the bottom of each stick adds a layer of versatility that’s often missing in similar products.
Overall, the design is both functional and fashionable, making these eyeshadow sticks a joy to use.
Creamy Texture and Blendability
In terms of texture and blendability, Rare Beauty’s eyeshadow sticks excel. The formula is exceptionally creamy and smooth, allowing for effortless application.
This is largely due to key ingredients like dimethicone and synthetic wax, which contribute to the product’s super soft and blendable nature.
The eyeshadow sticks glide smoothly onto the eyelid, ensuring a hassle-free experience.
TIP
If you live in a hot or humid area, make sure to amp up your primer game. Be mindful of the product heating up, as it can crack or break easily—especially on oily lids.
The blendability of these sticks is notable. Whether you’re using your fingers or a brush, the product blends seamlessly (in ideal conditions) without any patches or chunks.
Even as a gel cream eyeshadow, Rare Beauty stands out for its superior performance in this category.
The water-resistant gel formula ensures that the eyeshadow remains intact throughout the day. This feature, combined with the rich, shimmery finish provided by ingredients like synthetic fluorphlogopite, makes these eyeshadow sticks a must-have in any makeup collection.
Whether you’re aiming for a subtle daytime look or a bold evening style, these eyeshadow sticks have you covered.
Shade Range
Rare Beauty’s All Of The Above Weightless Eyeshadow Sticks are available in six stunning shades that you’ll absolutely love:
Integrity
Contentment
Well-Being
Compassion
Growth
Adventure
The range includes six shades, from soft pinks to deeper hues, offering limited options for different looks. The pigmentation isn’t particularly strong, so while the shades provide some variety, they may not be as vibrant as you’d hope.
For example, ‘Contentment’ and ‘Growth’ use standard ingredients like iron oxides, but they don’t deliver the intense color payoff you might expect.
Overall, the shades offer basic performance and might not stand out as much as some other products.
Putting It to the Test
I tested Rare Beauty’s eyeshadow sticks in some pretty tough conditions as we had a heatwave where I live in Canada. They held up decently well, keeping their color and not creasing even in the humidity (I used eye primer).
The only thing to watch out for is that without intervention the creamy formula can break down in high heat. But overall, they performed solidly and are a good pick for long days or special events where you need your makeup to last.
TIP
Don’t extend the formula too much while applying or the tip will break off!
Layering Different Shades
One cool thing about Rare Beauty’s eyeshadow sticks is that you can layer different shades without messing up the base color.
Unlike many cream eyeshadows that turn into a muddy mess when layered, these sticks keep their colors bright and separate.
Even with more neutral shades, the layers stay clear and look great.
Whether you’re going for a subtle gradient or a bold, layered look, these sticks make it super easy to build up your eyeshadow.
If you want to layer this with different eyeshadows you can use the gel cream as a base and then use powders on top to give it a more dynamic look.
Is It Worth the Hype?
So, does the Rare Beauty All Of The Above Weightless Eyeshadow Stick live up to the hype? Based on our thorough testing, we can confidently say yes.
These eyeshadow sticks offer excellent performance in terms of application, durability, and finish.
Whether you’re a makeup novice or a seasoned pro, these sticks are easy to use and provide an elegant look suitable for both day and night occasions.
The value for money is also commendable. While there are pricier and more cost effective alternatives on the market, Rare Beauty’s eyeshadow sticks deliver top-notch quality at a reasonable price. If you’re looking to invest in a versatile and reliable eyeshadow product, these sticks are worth considering.
My Review out of 10
Overall Review: 8.4
Performance: 8/10
The Rare Beauty eyeshadow sticks excel in performance with their creamy texture and long-lasting wear. While they handle layering well, they might not deliver the most intense color payoff, but overall, they hold up impressively well.
Ingredients: 8/10
The ingredients used in these eyeshadow sticks, like Dimethicone and Tocopheryl Acetate, contribute to a smooth and blendable formula. However, some ingredients like Trisiloxane and Microcrystalline Wax might not be ideal for all skin types, potentially leading to buildup or irritation for sensitive users.
Packaging: 9/10
The packaging of these eyeshadow sticks is both sleek and functional. The modern, slim design includes a built-in sharpener, which adds convenience and makes them easy to use on the go. The sturdy and stylish casing is a nice touch that enhances the overall user experience.
Price: 8/10
Priced reasonably for a vegan and cruelty-free product, these eyeshadow sticks offer good quality but aren’t the cheapest option out there. They provide solid performance and value, though some budget-friendly alternatives might offer similar results for less.
Brand Reputation: 9/10
Rare Beauty has a strong reputation for delivering high-quality beauty products. Known for their innovative formulas and effective products, the brand continues to build on its positive image, making these eyeshadow sticks a reliable choice for makeup enthusiasts.
Summary
In summary, the Rare Beauty All Of The Above Weightless Eyeshadow Sticks deliver on their promises of creamy texture, blendability, and long-lasting wear. From their sleek design to their versatile shade range, these eyeshadow sticks are a fantastic addition to any makeup collection.
They perform well under various conditions, with or without a primer, and offer good value for money.
Whether you’re new to makeup or a seasoned enthusiast, these eyeshadow sticks provide a reliable and easy-to-use option for creating beautiful eye looks. So, are they worth the hype? Absolutely.
Rare Beauty has once again proven why they are a beloved brand in the beauty world.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are the Rare Beauty eyeshadow sticks really crease-resistant?
Yes, the Rare Beauty eyeshadow sticks are crease-resistant, BUT make sure you pay extra attention when you live in places that are hot or humid. To prevent creasing I recommend using a eye primer as a base, using a less-is-more approach and to set with a similar powdered eyeshadow.
Do the eyeshadow sticks need a primer to last all day?
You don’t necessarily need a primer for eyeshadow sticks to last all day, but using one can help them last a bit longer and avoid separating due to heat and oils.
Can these eyeshadow sticks be used for highlighting?
Yes, you can use these eyeshadow sticks to highlight specific areas like the inner corner of the eye or under the brow bone. They work great for adding some shimmer to those areas!
How do they compare to other high-end brands?
Rare Beauty eyeshadow goes toe-to-toe with many high-end alternatives in texture, blendability, and overall performance. It’s a top contender in the high-end makeup market.
